vs Tally Prime

ASTech ERP vs Tally Prime — Why Businesses Are Switching

An honest comparison of ASTech ERP and Tally Prime for Indian businesses. See features, pricing, and support.

Get Started FreeView Pricing

Feature Comparison

See how ASTech ERP stacks up against Tally Prime

FeatureASTech ERPTally Prime
Access methodBrowser-based, any device, no installationDesktop installation; cloud access needs third-party hosting
POS for retailBuilt-in POS with offline mode, barcode scanning, and table managementBasic POS module; lacks offline sync and modern retail features
GST return filingGSTR-1, GSTR-3B, and GSTR-9 data auto-generated with JSON exportStrong GST support; JSON export available but requires Tally-specific navigation
Mobile appFull-featured Android/iOS app for billing, stock, and approvalsTally Mobile Bank, limited to viewing reports; no billing from mobile
HR and payrollFull payroll with PF, ESI, PT, TDS, Form 16, and EPF ECRPayroll available only in higher editions; limited HR features
WhatsApp integrationSend invoices, payment reminders, and statements via WhatsAppNo native WhatsApp integration; requires third-party add-ons
AI-powered insightsSales predictions, inventory forecasting, and anomaly alertsNo AI features; traditional reports only
Pricing modelSubscription from ₹999/month; all features included per planOne-time license + annual maintenance; costs higher for multi-user

Tally Prime Limitations

Desktop-only installation, no true cloud access

Tally Prime is installed on a local PC. Remote access requires Tally on Cloud (a third-party hosting service at additional cost) or a VPN setup. There is no native browser-based interface — you cannot open your books from a phone browser or a non-Tally computer.

No built-in CRM or customer portal

Tally has no customer relationship management features. You cannot send payment reminders via WhatsApp, create a customer payment portal, or track customer communication history within the software.

Limited POS functionality

Tally's POS module is basic and lacks modern retail features like offline billing with auto-sync, table management for restaurants, or integrated loyalty programmes. Most retailers using Tally use a separate POS system alongside it.

No HR or payroll module in the base product

Tally Prime's standard editions do not include payroll. You need Tally Prime with Payroll (a higher-priced edition) or a third-party add-on. Payroll features like full-and-final settlement and Form 16 generation require configuration.

Steep learning curve for non-accountants

Tally's interface uses accounting shortcut keys and terminology designed for professional accountants. Business owners and operations staff often struggle with routine tasks like creating purchase orders or checking stock levels without training.

How to Switch from Tally Prime to ASTech ERP

1

Export your master data from Tally: go to Gateway of Tally → Import/Export → Export Masters. Export the company data in XML format, which includes ledgers (customers, vendors), stock items, and opening balances.

2

Export your transaction history: for the last 2–3 years of data, export vouchers (sales, purchases, journal entries) as XML or use the Tally Data Export Utility. This gives you the historical transaction trail.

3

Import masters into ASTech ERP using the provided migration templates: map Tally ledger groups to ASTech account types, import stock items with HSN codes and units, and set opening balances as of your migration date.

4

Verify opening balances: run a trial balance comparison between Tally and ASTech ERP for the migration date to confirm all balances match before going live.

5

Run parallel for 15 days: create the same transactions in both systems during the transition period to validate that ASTech ERP produces identical GST and accounting outputs, then switch completely.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I import all my Tally data into ASTech ERP without losing history?+
Yes. ASTech ERP's migration tool accepts Tally's XML export format for masters (ledgers, stock items) and supports opening balance import for all account heads. Transaction history from Tally can be brought in as opening balances per account. Our support team assists with the migration at no additional charge.
Will ASTech ERP handle the same GST reports that Tally generates?+
Yes. ASTech ERP generates GSTR-1 (JSON and Excel), GSTR-3B summary, GSTR-2A reconciliation, GSTR-9 annual return data, and ITC-04 for job work. The output format is identical to what the GST portal accepts, and in some cases easier to use than Tally's navigation.
My accountant is familiar with Tally. Will they have trouble using ASTech ERP?+
ASTech ERP uses standard accounting terminology and double-entry principles — any accountant familiar with Tally will be comfortable with the accounting module within a few days. The interface is more visual and browser-based, which most accountants find easier than Tally's keyboard-shortcut-heavy navigation.
What happens to my Tally license if I switch to ASTech ERP?+
Your Tally license is separate from ASTech ERP — you can keep it for reference access to old records. Many businesses keep Tally available for 1–2 years after migration purely for historical lookup while running all new transactions in ASTech ERP.

Explore More

Make the Switch to ASTech ERP Today

Thousands of businesses have already migrated from Tally Prime. See why ASTech ERP is the smarter choice for Indian businesses.

Get Started Free